Why can't I get a loan, even with a good credit score?
Lenders check both your credit history and whether you can afford the repayments from your income, so you can be refused with a good score because of affordability, too many recent applications, errors or gaps on your credit file, or the lender's own criteria.
Test what you can realistically afford: see how the monthly payment changes with the amount and term in our loan calculator.
Open the loan calculatorLenders run two separate tests
A good credit score only answers half the question. Under FCA rules, before lending a lender must assess your creditworthiness, which covers two different risks:
- Credit risk: how likely you are to repay, judged largely from your credit file and history.
- Affordability risk: whether you can make the repayments out of your income without having to borrow to do it, without missing other bills you're obliged to pay, and without the repayments having a significant adverse impact on your finances.
You can pass the first and fail the second. That's why people with "excellent" scores on an app are still turned down. The score you see is the app's own estimate. Each lender uses its own scoring, with its own data and its own idea of the customer it wants.
The most common reasons for a refusal
- Affordability. Your income, after rent or mortgage, bills and existing credit payments, doesn't leave enough headroom for the new payment. Owning a home doesn't fix this, because the test is about income.
- Something on your credit file. Missed payments, defaults, county court judgments, insolvency records or high balances. A default stays on your file for 6 years from the default date.
- Not enough history. If you've had little or no credit, lenders have less evidence to go on.
- Identity and address problems. Credit files include electoral roll and address data. If your electoral roll details are missing or wrong, or you've just moved, lenders may not be able to confirm who you are.
- Lots of recent applications. The ICO explains that searches shouldn't count against you in themselves, but many searches in a short space of time can suggest you're struggling to get credit, and that can affect decisions.
- Financial links. If you share credit, such as a joint account or loan, with someone whose file has problems, lenders may take their record into account.
- Errors. Accounts that aren't yours, wrong addresses or debts already settled but still showing.
- The lender's own criteria. Minimum income, employment type, age, residency or loan purpose. Sometimes you simply aren't the customer that product is designed for.
How to find out why
Nobody has a right to credit, but you do have rights to information:
- Ask the lender. The ICO says you can ask a lender to explain the main reason for a refusal and to review its decision, though it may still say no.
- Which credit reference agency was used. If a lender turns you down because of information from a credit reference agency, the Consumer Credit Act says it must tell you so and give that agency's name, address and phone number.
- Get your statutory credit report, free. You can ask any of the three main agencies, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, for the information they hold about your financial standing. It's free, you can ask verbally or in writing, and they normally have one month to respond. Look for the "statutory report" option; you don't need a paid subscription.
What to do next
- Stop applying for a while. Each refusal can add another search footprint, and many searches close together look bad.
- Check all three credit files. Lenders don't have to report to every agency, so one file can differ from another. Dispute errors with the agency, or with the lender that supplied the data.
- Add a Notice of Correction if there's a genuine explanation for a past problem, such as illness or a billing dispute.
- Make sure you're on the electoral register at your current address, and that your address details are correct everywhere.
- Use eligibility checkers that use a soft search before making full applications.
- Rework the numbers. A smaller loan, a longer term or clearing an existing card may bring the payment within what a lender considers affordable.
If you're borrowing to cover everyday bills or other debts, take that as a warning sign. Free debt advice, for example through MoneyHelper, can help you find options that don't involve more borrowing.
Worked example
Chris has a credit score his app calls "excellent" and applies for a £10,000 personal loan over 3 years at an interest rate of 9.9% a year.
- His take-home pay is £2,100 a month. Rent, bills, food, travel and his existing car finance come to £1,650, leaving £2,100 − £1,650 = £450.
- The loan payment would be about £322.20 a month (monthly rate 9.9% ÷ 12 over 36 months). That would leave £450 − £322.20 = £127.80 a month for everything unexpected.
- Total repaid: £322.20 × 36 = about £11,599, so roughly £1,599 of interest.
The lender's affordability model decides that £127.80 is too thin a buffer and declines him. His credit history was never the problem. If he borrows £6,000 instead over the same term, the payment drops to about £193 a month, leaving about £257, which is far more likely to pass.
Why was I refused a loan when my credit score is good?#
Lenders check affordability as well as your credit history, and FCA rules require them to. If your income after bills and existing debts doesn't leave enough room for the repayment, you can be declined with a spotless record. Each lender also uses its own scoring, not the score you see in an app.
Can I find out why my loan application was declined?#
Yes. You can ask the lender to explain the main reason and review its decision. If the refusal was based on credit reference agency data, it must tell you so and give you that agency's details, so you can check what it holds.
How do I check my credit file for free?#
Ask Equifax, Experian or TransUnion for your statutory credit report, which is free, verbally or in writing. They normally have one month to reply. You don't need to sign up to a paid subscription.
Does applying for lots of loans hurt my chances?#
It can. The ICO says searches shouldn't count against you in themselves, but many searches in a short time can suggest you're struggling to get credit. Use soft-search eligibility checkers and space out full applications.
Why can't I get a loan even though I own a house?#
Owning a home doesn't prove you can afford monthly repayments. For unsecured loans, lenders assess whether your income can cover the payments without hardship. A secured loan uses your home as security, so get advice before putting it at risk.
Could not being on the electoral roll stop me getting a loan?#
It can make it harder, because credit files use electoral roll data to confirm who you are and where you live. Register at your current address. If your file shows the wrong electoral roll details, dispute them with the credit reference agency.
What should I do if I keep getting refused credit?#
Stop applying, get your free statutory reports from all three agencies and fix any errors. Then look at whether a smaller amount or a longer term would be affordable. If you need the money for bills or other debts, speak to a free debt adviser first.
Keep reading
- How do I set up a self-managed debt management plan (DMP)?Related question
- What are the downsides of a credit card if you pay it off in full?Related question
- Loan repayment (EMI) and amortization calculatorCalculator
- More on loans & car financeTopic hub
- Why has my ClearScore credit score dropped?People also read
- Should I close credit cards I don't use?People also read
- Should I keep my old credit card open or close it?People also read
Sources
- FCA Handbook CONC 5.2A: Creditworthiness assessment (credit risk and affordability risk)
- ICO: Credit – credit reference agencies, refused credit and your statutory credit report
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Credit Act 1974, section 157 – duty to disclose name of credit reference agency
- Principles for the Reporting of Arrears, Arrangements and Defaults at Credit Reference Agencies (with ICO foreword)
General information, not personal financial advice. Rules depend on your circumstances; check the official source or speak to a regulated adviser before acting.